Virtual Assistant vs Employee: The True Cost for UK Small Businesses
When admin work starts to overwhelm you, there are two obvious solutions: hire someone, or outsource. Most owners assume hiring is cheaper because the hourly rate looks lower. In practice, the comparison is closer than it appears — and for many small businesses, outsourcing wins.
This article does not argue that outsourcing is always better. It sets out the true cost of each option, clearly and honestly, so you can make the decision based on your own numbers.
What a part-time employee really costs
A part-time admin employee in the UK might be advertised at £12–£15 per hour. That is the wage. It is not the cost.
On top of the wage, an employer pays:
- Employer National Insurance contributions — 15% on earnings above the secondary threshold.
- Pension contributions — a minimum of 3% of qualifying earnings under auto-enrolment.
- Holiday pay — 5.6 weeks of statutory paid holiday per year, pro-rated for part-time staff.
- Sick pay — statutory sick pay for qualifying employees.
- Recruitment costs — advertising, interviewing, onboarding.
- Equipment and software — laptop, phone, licences, possibly a desk.
- Management time — someone has to supervise, train and manage the person.
- Cover costs — when the employee is on holiday or sick, someone else has to do the work or it does not get done.
When you add these up, the true hourly cost of a part-time admin hire is typically 30–50% higher than the headline wage. A role advertised at £14 an hour may actually cost £20–£21 per hour once everything is included.
This is not an argument against employment. It is an argument for accounting for the full cost. Our existing article, Virtual Assistant vs Hiring Part Time Admin, covers this ground in more detail.
What outsourced support costs
Outsourced admin support through Hands Off Support costs £20–£30 per hour depending on the package. There are no employer National Insurance contributions, no pension, no holiday pay, no recruitment costs, no equipment costs and no management overhead. You buy hours. You use them. You adjust them as needed.
Current packages:
- Starter — 10 hours/month at £30/hour (first month £150, then £300/month).
- Growth — 20 hours/month at £25/hour (first month £250, then £500/month).
- Professional — 40+ hours/month at £20/hour (first month £400, then £800/month).
- Pay as you go — £40/hour, minimum two hours.
See the full breakdown on the pricing section.
The comparison, side by side
Take a simple example. You need 20 hours of admin support per month.
Option A: Part-time employee
- Advertised wage: £14/hour × 20 hours × 52 weeks = £14,560/year
- Employer NI (15% on earnings above threshold): approximately £1,500/year
- Pension (3% minimum): approximately £400/year
- Holiday cover (5.6 weeks pro-rated): approximately £1,570/year
- Recruitment and onboarding (one-off): £500–£1,500
- Equipment and software: £300–£600/year
- Management time: hard to quantify, but real
- Approximate annual cost: £18,800–£20,100
Option B: Outsourced admin support (Growth package)
- 20 hours/month × £25/hour = £500/month
- Annual cost: £6,000
- No NI, pension, holiday cover, recruitment, equipment or management overhead
That is a difference of £12,000–£14,000 per year for the same number of hours.
These figures are illustrative, not guarantees. Your circumstances will vary. NI thresholds, pension rules and wage rates change. But the direction of the comparison is robust: employment carries significant costs that the hourly wage does not show.
You can model your own scenario with the cost calculator.
What you give up with outsourcing
Honesty matters here. Outsourcing is not identical to employment.
An employee is available on site. They can cover a reception desk, handle physical paperwork, manage post and be present for walk-in enquiries. Outsourced support is remote. It handles digital and phone-based admin, not physical presence.
An employee is also exclusively yours during their hours. An outsourced admin may work with a small number of other clients, though Hands Off Support operates a one-person-per-client model so you get a consistent point of contact rather than a rotating pool.
If your admin needs are genuinely on-site and physical, an employee is the right answer. If they are digital, phone-based and task-driven, outsourcing usually wins on cost and flexibility.
Flexibility: the underrated factor
Cost is not the only difference. Flexibility matters.
With an employee, you commit to fixed hours every week. If work is quiet, you still pay. If work surges, you cannot easily add hours without overtime or a new contract. If the person leaves, you start again.
With outsourced support, hours flex. You can start at 10 hours and move to 20 when work increases. You can drop back during quiet periods. You can stop entirely if circumstances change. There is no lock-in, no notice period and no recruitment risk.
For a growing business, that flexibility is often worth more than the hourly saving.
When employment is the right choice
Outsourcing is not always the answer.
Employ if:
- You need someone physically present.
- Your admin involves handling physical documents, stock or equipment.
- You want someone who is exclusively focused on your business during their hours.
- You need a long-term, full-time presence and the work is genuinely continuous.
- You want to train someone into a broader role over time.
Outsource if:
- Your admin is digital, phone-based or task-driven.
- Your workload varies week to week or month to month.
- You are not ready for the commitment of employment.
- You want to test whether support helps before committing to a hire.
- You value flexibility over physical presence.
For many small businesses, the right answer is to outsource first and hire later if the need grows. You can read more about this route in Admin Help When You Cannot Hire Another Person.
How to decide
Write down the tasks you want handled. Estimate the hours. Then ask two questions:
- Does this work need to happen on site?
- Does this work need to happen at fixed times every week?
If the answer to both is no, outsourced support is worth pricing. If the answer to either is yes, employment may be the better fit.
The numbers above are a starting point, not a final answer. Your actual cost depends on your circumstances. But the gap between the advertised wage and the true cost of employment is real, and it is often larger than owners expect.
If you want to see what outsourced support would cost for your specific workload, arrange a discovery call. You will get a scoped quote with no obligation. You can also read our full breakdown of what outsourced admin support costs in the UK and the practical guide to phone answering for trades for related context.
Ready to compare costs for your workload?
Enquire nowRelated: VA vs hiring part time · Outsourced admin cost UK · Admin help when you cannot hire